As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Chester A. Arthur: 21st U.S. President | Civil Service Reform, Pendleton Act & Presidential Relic

• • • • • • •
The Sovereign Executive · Presidential Relic No. 21

Chester A. Arthur served as the 21st President of the United States from 1881 to 1885, taking office after the assassination of President James A. Garfield. Once closely associated with New York's political patronage system, Arthur became one of the Gilded Age's most unexpected advocates of federal civil service reform. His administration also confronted immigration restrictions, tariff policy and the urgent need to rebuild an aging United States Navy.

Chester A. Arthur 21st President Sovereign Vault Presidential Relic card featuring Presidential Coat and Chester Arthur Task artifacts

The Sovereign Vault Chester A. Arthur card presents two fictional collectible elements: a Presidential Coat textile relic and the card's “Chester Arthur Task” artifact relic, set against imagery inspired by the politics and atmosphere of the Gilded Age.

Chester A. Arthur: Presidency at a Glance
Presidential Number 21st President
Political Party Republican
Presidential Term September 20, 1881 – March 4, 1885
Vice President None during his presidency
Born October 5, 1829
Birthplace Fairfield, Vermont
Predecessor James A. Garfield
Successor Grover Cleveland
Major Reform Pendleton Civil Service Reform Act
Died November 18, 1886

Inside the Chester A. Arthur Presidential Relic

Sovereign Vault Lore

The Chester A. Arthur Presidential Relic card contains two original fictional artifacts designed to evoke Arthur's distinctive personality and the Gilded Age world in which he governed.

The first is labeled “Presidential Coat – Textile Relic.”

That choice fits Arthur particularly well. He became famous for his elaborate personal appearance, carefully tailored clothing, impressive side whiskers and highly polished social style. Newspapers sometimes portrayed him as one of the most fashionable men ever to occupy the White House.

The second collectible is labeled “Chester Arthur Task – Artifact Relic.”

Within The Sovereign Vault, it functions as an artistic object associated with Arthur's presidency rather than an authenticated historical artifact.

Neither relic is represented as an actual object once owned, worn or used by Chester A. Arthur. They are original fictional components created to frame the historical story around the 21st president.

From Vermont to New York

Chester Alan Arthur was born on October 5, 1829, in Fairfield, Vermont.

His father, William Arthur, was a Baptist minister and immigrant from Ireland. The family moved frequently during Chester's childhood as his father served different congregations.

Arthur eventually attended Union College in Schenectady, New York, graduating in 1848.

After teaching school, he studied law and established a legal career in New York City.

A Young Lawyer and Civil Rights Case

Arthur's early legal career included work on cases involving racial discrimination in public transportation.

He became connected with the legal effort surrounding Elizabeth Jennings Graham, a Black New York teacher who was forcibly removed from a segregated streetcar in 1854.

Jennings successfully challenged the streetcar company in court, and the case became part of the longer movement against racial segregation on New York transportation.

Arthur's association with abolitionist legal circles reflected the strongly antislavery Republican environment in which his political career later developed.

Arthur During the Civil War

When the Civil War began, Arthur served in the New York state militia.

His most important wartime responsibilities were administrative rather than battlefield commands.

Arthur became quartermaster general of New York, responsible for helping equip, transport and supply troops.

The position demanded significant organizational skill as thousands of soldiers passed through the state's military system.

His effectiveness in managing logistics helped build his reputation inside New York Republican politics.

The New York Customs House

Arthur's political rise became closely tied to Senator Roscoe Conkling and New York's powerful Republican political organization.

In 1871, President Ulysses S. Grant appointed Arthur collector of the Port of New York.

The New York Custom House was one of the most politically valuable federal offices in the country.

It collected enormous amounts of tariff revenue and employed a large federal workforce.

Government jobs were commonly distributed through the political patronage system—often called the spoils system—in which public positions could reward loyal party workers.

Arthur operated comfortably inside that system.

Hayes Removes Arthur

President Rutherford B. Hayes entered office determined to reform federal patronage practices.

The New York Custom House became one of the central battlegrounds.

Hayes eventually removed Arthur from his position in 1878.

Arthur's dismissal strengthened his association with the Republican faction known as the Stalwarts, whose leaders defended traditional patronage and opposed the civil service reforms promoted by Hayes and other reform Republicans.

The Republican Convention of 1880

Republicans arrived at their 1880 national convention deeply divided.

The Stalwarts supported former President Grant for another term.

Other factions backed different candidates.

After a prolonged convention, delegates eventually selected Ohio Congressman James A. Garfield as the presidential nominee.

To help balance the ticket politically and geographically, Chester Arthur was chosen as the vice-presidential nominee.

Garfield and Arthur won the election.

Vice President Chester Arthur

Arthur became vice president in March 1881.

His political relationship with President Garfield was complicated almost immediately by a battle over federal appointments.

Arthur remained aligned with Roscoe Conkling and the Stalwart faction while Garfield sought greater control over presidential appointments in New York.

The dispute represented a larger struggle over whether federal offices belonged to party organizations or to the president and professional government service.

The Assassination of James Garfield

On July 2, 1881, President Garfield was shot at the Baltimore and Potomac Railroad Station in Washington by Charles Guiteau.

Guiteau had unsuccessfully sought a government position and considered himself entitled to political patronage.

Garfield survived for more than two months while physicians attempted to treat his wounds.

He died on September 19, 1881.

The assassination intensified public anger toward the patronage system because Guiteau repeatedly connected his actions to his frustrated effort to obtain government employment.

Arthur Becomes the 21st President

Arthur received news of Garfield's death while at his home in New York.

Shortly after midnight on September 20, 1881, he took the presidential oath there.

He later repeated the oath in Washington.

The change produced considerable public anxiety.

Arthur had been closely identified with machine politics and patronage, while Garfield had become associated with resistance to those forces.

Many reformers therefore expected Arthur to reverse course.

Instead, his presidency surprised them.

An unexpected transformation: Arthur entered national office as a prominent product of the patronage system. Yet after becoming president, he supported the most important federal civil service reform law enacted up to that time.

The Pendleton Civil Service Reform Act

Public pressure for reform grew rapidly after Garfield's assassination.

Congress eventually passed the Pendleton Civil Service Reform Act, and Arthur signed it into law in January 1883.

The law established a bipartisan United States Civil Service Commission.

It created a classified federal service in which certain government positions would be filled through competitive examinations rather than purely political appointment.

The law also prohibited some forms of political assessments imposed on federal workers.

At first, only part of the federal workforce came under the new system.

Over time, however, the classified civil service expanded dramatically.

The Pendleton Act helped establish the principle that many government positions should be awarded according to qualifications rather than party loyalty.

Why Arthur's Reform Mattered

Arthur's support for the Pendleton Act was particularly notable because his own political career had benefited from the system the law began to dismantle.

He did not become a modern civil service reformer overnight, nor did patronage disappear.

But his willingness to sign and administer the legislation marked an important shift.

The federal government increasingly moved toward a professional bureaucracy whose employees could remain in service across changes of presidential administration.

The Chinese Exclusion Act

Arthur's presidency also coincided with one of the most consequential immigration laws in American history.

Anti-Chinese political sentiment had become particularly intense in the western United States.

Congress initially passed legislation that would have suspended Chinese labor immigration for twenty years.

Arthur vetoed that bill.

He argued that a twenty-year suspension went beyond the terms of the United States' treaty obligations with China.

Congress then passed a revised measure imposing a ten-year restriction.

Arthur signed the revised Chinese Exclusion Act in May 1882.

The act suspended the immigration of Chinese laborers and represented an unprecedented federal restriction directed against a particular nationality.

Its restrictions were later extended and strengthened.

Important distinction: Arthur did veto the first twenty-year exclusion bill, but he subsequently signed the revised ten-year Chinese Exclusion Act. Both facts are important to understanding his record.

Immigration Act of 1882

The federal government's role in immigration expanded in other ways during Arthur's presidency.

The Immigration Act of 1882 imposed a federal head tax on arriving immigrants and excluded certain categories of people from entry.

The law represented another step toward transforming immigration regulation from a largely state and local responsibility into a federal function.

Arthur and the Tariff Debate

Tariff revenue was another major political issue.

Because the federal government depended heavily on tariffs for income, high duties had produced substantial government surpluses.

Arthur favored reducing tariff rates.

Congress enacted the Tariff Act of 1883, sometimes called the Mongrel Tariff because its mixture of increases and reductions satisfied neither strong protectionists nor advocates of substantial reform.

The tariff debate remained unresolved and became an even larger political issue during the presidencies that followed Arthur.

Beginning the Modern Steel Navy

One of Arthur's more enduring contributions came at sea.

By the early 1880s, much of the United States Navy consisted of aging wooden or Civil War-era ships.

European naval powers were adopting steel construction, improved steam propulsion and increasingly sophisticated weapons.

Arthur urged Congress to modernize the American fleet.

In 1883, Congress authorized construction of a new group of steel vessels.

The cruisers Atlanta, Boston and Chicago, together with the dispatch vessel Dolphin, became collectively associated with the beginning of the United States' modern steel Navy.

These ships did not instantly transform the fleet, but the program marked an important departure from decades of post-Civil War decline.

Naval expansion accelerated during later administrations and helped prepare the United States for its growing overseas role at the end of the 19th century.

The Presidential Succession Problem

When Arthur became president, there was no constitutional mechanism for filling a vacancy in the vice presidency.

His vice-presidential office therefore remained vacant from September 1881 until the end of his presidency in March 1885.

The situation underscored weaknesses in the country's presidential succession system.

Congress later enacted the Presidential Succession Act of 1886, shortly after Arthur left office.

The process for filling a vacant vice presidency would not be created until ratification of the 25th Amendment in the 20th century.

Renovating the White House

Arthur brought his well-known interest in appearance and interior design into the Executive Mansion.

Before fully moving into the White House, he ordered extensive redecoration.

Louis Comfort Tiffany—who later became internationally famous for decorative glass—was among those involved in transforming the interior.

Victorian furnishings were replaced or redesigned, and portions of the White House received dramatically updated decorative treatments.

The changes reflected Arthur's reputation for elegance, but later renovations removed much of the decoration associated with his administration.

The President Known for Style

Arthur's appearance became part of his public image.

He was tall, carefully groomed and famous for his elaborate side whiskers.

Contemporary accounts emphasized his wardrobe and social life.

He acquired nicknames such as “Elegant Arthur.”

The fashionable reputation sometimes obscures the political importance of his presidency, particularly his role in implementing civil service reform and supporting naval modernization.

Ellen Arthur and the White House

Arthur entered the presidency as a widower.

His wife, Ellen “Nell” Herndon Arthur, had died of pneumonia in January 1880, before Arthur became vice president.

He was deeply affected by her death.

Arthur's sister Mary Arthur McElroy later served as White House hostess during social events.

Arthur never remarried.

A Secret Illness

Not long after becoming president, Arthur learned that he suffered from Bright's disease, a serious kidney disorder.

He largely concealed the severity of his health problems from the public.

Arthur's declining health influenced the final years of his life and may have reduced his enthusiasm for aggressively seeking another presidential term.

The Election of 1884

Arthur allowed his name to remain in consideration for the Republican presidential nomination in 1884.

However, he did not mount the kind of aggressive campaign that might have been expected from an incumbent president.

Republicans instead nominated James G. Blaine.

Democrat Grover Cleveland won the general election.

Arthur completed his term and left the White House on March 4, 1885.

Life After the Presidency

Arthur returned to New York City after leaving office.

His health continued to deteriorate.

He attempted to resume legal work but was increasingly limited by illness.

Chester A. Arthur died on November 18, 1886, less than two years after leaving the presidency.

He was 57 years old.

Chester A. Arthur Presidential Timeline

October 5, 1829
Chester Alan Arthur is born in Fairfield, Vermont.
1848
Arthur graduates from Union College in New York.
1850s
He studies law, begins practicing in New York City and becomes involved in Republican and antislavery politics.
1859
Arthur marries Ellen “Nell” Herndon.
1861–1863
During the Civil War, Arthur serves in important administrative and quartermaster positions for New York.
1871
President Ulysses S. Grant appoints Arthur collector of the Port of New York.
1878
President Rutherford B. Hayes removes Arthur from the New York Custom House during a battle over civil service reform.
January 1880
Arthur's wife Nell dies of pneumonia.
1880
Republicans nominate James Garfield for president and Chester Arthur for vice president.
March 3, 1881
Arthur takes the vice-presidential oath.
July 2, 1881
President James Garfield is shot in Washington.
September 19, 1881
Garfield dies from complications following the shooting.
September 20, 1881
Chester A. Arthur succeeds Garfield as the 21st President of the United States.
May 1882
Arthur signs the revised Chinese Exclusion Act after vetoing an earlier twenty-year version.
1882
Arthur calls for a major rehabilitation of the United States Navy.
January 1883
Arthur signs the Pendleton Civil Service Reform Act.
1883
Congress authorizes construction of the steel vessels that become associated with the beginning of the modern American steel Navy.
1884
Arthur fails to win the Republican presidential nomination; James G. Blaine becomes the party's nominee.
March 4, 1885
Arthur leaves office as Grover Cleveland begins his first presidential term.
November 18, 1886
Chester A. Arthur dies in New York City at age 57.

Arthur's Place in Presidential History

Chester A. Arthur remains one of the more unusual figures to occupy the presidency.

Few presidents entered office with such a strong association with the political system they later helped reform.

Arthur had risen through the New York Republican machine and had openly defended patronage.

Yet as president, he signed legislation that began replacing political appointment with competitive examinations across portions of the federal workforce.

His administration also helped begin the transformation of an aging post-Civil War naval force into a modern steel Navy.

At the same time, Arthur's signature on the Chinese Exclusion Act placed his presidency within a deeply restrictive chapter of American immigration policy.

Those different parts of his record make Arthur difficult to reduce to a single label.

He was a machine politician who supported reform, an elegant social figure who governed during serious institutional change, and a president who arrived in office unexpectedly after national tragedy.

πŸ›️ Enter the Presidential Vault

Chester A. Arthur entered the presidency after James Garfield's assassination and became one of the Gilded Age's most unexpected reform presidents. Continue through The Sovereign Executive to explore every completed presidential record and Presidential Relic.

Explore All Presidential Relics →

Continue Through Presidential History

The Sovereign Vault Presidential Relic artwork is an original fictional collectible inspired by historical people, events and public imagery. The Presidential Coat and Chester Arthur Task relic displayed on this card are artistic representations and are not represented as authentic Chester A. Arthur artifacts.

 
⚠ RESTRICTED ARCHIVE
CLASSIFIED VAULT RECORD
Clearance Required
SUBJECT:
ARCHIVE:
ORIGIN:
STATUS: RESTRICTED
This record has been sealed inside the Sovereign Vault.

Authorization is required before its contents may be revealed.
FILE: SV-CLASSIFIED
FILE DECLASSIFIED
πŸ”“ AUTHORIZED RELEASE
Sovereign Vault Record
ARCHIVE STATUS: RELEASED
πŸ” ENTER DECLASSIFIED FILE →
🎲 FEELING LUCKY?
Let the Vault choose your next discovery.